Are you wondering which are the best restaurants in Islamorada, Florida? Wonder no more.
In this article, we will walk you through where to find the best food in Islamorada and tell you everything you need to know about the food scene in this area.
It’s a little bit of paradise with beautiful weather, some of the best beaches in the Keys, and perfect blue water. It’s actually a town made up of six islands so there are lots of beaches to explore and plenty of water to swim in.
If you want to visit the Florida Keys and want to stay away from the tourist area and all the trappings that come with that then Islamorada is for you. These islands are much more laid back and less crowded than their more famous neighbors.
The envious position of this island means that the seafood in Islamorada is plentiful and incredible; consequently, the seafood restaurants are phenomenal. The Islamorada restaurants on the water are plentiful, the food available diverse, and the settings wonderful.
There is nothing as perfect as dining in Islamorada, the views are perfect, the seafood unbridled, and the laid-back vibe intoxicating.
So are you ready to see where to find the best Islamorada food? Grab a chair, get a cold drink and let us walk you through the best restaurants in Islamorada, Florida.
15 Best Restaurants In Islamorada FL You Must Try
One of the Islamorada restaurants on the water, Island Grill is a seafood-focused eatery with a view. It is located on the river on the south end of the Snake Creek Bridge.
This is one of the restaurants in Islamorada where the food really does the talking. Don’t expect fancy decor and sleek interiors this is more of a rustic beach bar vibe.
It’s a popular location with live music nightly and has been voted Islamorada’s best restaurant. Expect items such as Graham Crusted Calamari, Crack Conch Sandwich, and Lobster Roll. They do also have meat and vegetarian dishes.
This is one of the best Islamorada restaurants and really sums up that island feeling.
Tower Of Pizza
If you are looking for pizza in Islamorada then look no further than Tower of Pizza. The pizza is fresh and tasty and loved by locals.
It’s an unpretentious place that serves pizza, pasta, and subs for dine-in, take-out, or delivery. The dough is made fresh daily by hand and the ingredients are always fresh.
The menu here is extensive covering much more than just pizza. Everyone will be able to find something they love on this menu.
If you are wondering what to eat in Islamorada then you can’t go wrong with a great pizza.
Located in Plantation Key on one of the few natural beaches in the Florida Keys Marker 88 serves seafood, steaks, and other delights in an elegant yet casual atmosphere.
This is one of the best places for dinner in Islamorada with live music, great food, and an incredible view. The cocktails here are well known locally and the sunset views are unrivaled.
The food is fresh and innovative with items like Key Lime Seafood, Painted Tuna, and Shrimp Zoodles. This is definitely one of the best places to eat in Islamorada.
MEAT Eatery And Taproom
This is one of the coolest places to eat in Islamorada. It’s a brick-lined hangout serving pub grub in a casual atmosphere.
They are said to have some of the best burgers in Florida so if you love burgers this is the place for you. Here you will find innovative dishes, great craft beers, friendly staff, and high-quality food.
The Inside-Out Juicy Lucy Burger is one of the top-rated burgers in Florida, but it’s not just burgers. The Catch Of The Day Sandwich, Home Smoked Chicken Wings, and Chicken Tenders also grace the menu.
This is one of the best restaurants in Islamorada, Florida to come with a group of friends or a large family outing.
Lorelei Restaurant And Cabana Bar
One of the most famous restaurants in Islamorada this is the place to come for sunsets and cocktails. At happy hour this place is packed and when you visit you will see why.
As well as great food, you will find live music and live magicians, it’s a happening vibrant place. This restaurant is known as “The Pulse Of Islamorada” it serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner.
The menu includes items such as Coconut Shrimp, Sunset Conch Fritters, Stone Crab Chowder, and Lorelei’s World Famous Fish Sandwich. They do also serve meat dishes and vegetarian dishes.
Ciao Hound Italian Kitchen And Bar
If you are looking for Italian food in a down-to-earth environment then this is the place for you. This place is all about good food, great friends, and authentic Tuscan flavors.
The menu consists of the usual Italian-style dishes you would expect. It’s a small and concise menu but most will find something on it.
Baked Spinach Artichoke Fonduta, Pasta E Fagioli, Linguini Frutti Di Mare and Grouper Puttanesca all appear on the menu. Ciao Hound is a welcoming place and offers some of the best dining in Islamorada.
They also serve the best breakfast in Islamorada with the Breakfast Panini and Buttermilk Pancakes being popular items.
Square Grouper Islamorada
Located in the Islamorada Marina this restaurant is known for its fresh innovative seafood and extensive wine selection. It’s one of the most popular dining destinations in the Florida Keys so put this one high on your list.
The service is elevated, the food is high quality, and the atmosphere is just perfect. It’s the perfect place for dinner in Islamorada.
The menu includes such items as Fried Conch, Yellowfin Tuna And Avocado Eggrolls, Square Grouper Seafood Stew, and Truffled Lobster Mac.
If you are wondering where to eat in Islamorada give this restaurant a try you won’t be disappointed.
If you are wondering where to eat in Islamorada then this Italian restaurant offers great food and indoor and outdoor dining options. The Bayside Gourmet is a highly rated restaurant that offers a great dining experience.
This family-owned and operated establishment serves some of the best food in Islamorada with everything fresh and hand-prepared. The food is mouth-watering, the decor modern and simple and the atmosphere casual and welcoming.
The Pizzas are gourmet with vegetarian and meat delights. the menu also includes such items as Spaghetti and Homemade Meatballs, Homemade Lasagna, and a variety of meat and fish dishes.
One of the best restaurants in Islamorada, Florida.
Lazy Days Restaurant
Here you can dine on the beach, on the patio, on the porch, or inside. But wherever you sit the view is beautiful.
This restaurant is award-winning with countless awards, especially for its food, location, and staff. You know when you come here you are going to have a great experience.
They serve seafood, pasta, steaks, sandwiches, and other meat and vegetable dishes. They will also cook the fish you catch.
Menu items include such things as The Best Fried Cracked Conch, Oysters Moscow, Baked Brie, and Coconut Fried Shrimp. This low-key destination really does pack a punch.
Lazy Days is one of the best restaurants in Islamorada, FL and a visit here will be a great experience.
If you are wondering what to eat in Islamorada and are looking for something a bit more upscale then Chef Michael’s might be for you.
This is a dock-to-dish kind of restaurant and they will cook your caught fish for you. They also serve the best brunch in Islamorada here.
The menu is creative and contains fish, meat, and game dishes. Lamb Shank Braised In Castronovo Red, Tempura Shrimp & Asparagus, “Chop Chop” Chicken, and Crispy Roast Long Island Duck all appear on the menu.
This sophisticated eatery is a great place for a celebration. It’s casual yet elegant and the food is superb. Some of the best Islamorada food is served here.
Ziggie & Mad Dog’s
Known for its steak, chops, and seafood this is one of the restaurants in Islamorada that everyone will love. There has been a restaurant here since the 1950s and the building it occupies dates back to the 1930s.
It’s a casual sports bar-type setting and the menu is extensive and eclectic. Everyone will find something on this menu to suit them.
The menu includes items such as Fresh Florida Keys Stone Crabs, Lobster Tail And White Truffle Mac & Cheese, Beef Tenderloin Stroganoff, and Grilled Duck Breast.
This is one of the best Islamorada restaurants and they serve some of the best seafood in Islamorada.
Midway Cafe And Coffee Bar
If you are looking for breakfast in Islamorada then look no further than Midway Cafe And Coffee Bar. It’s a funky, colorful, vibrant place serving great food.
The baked goods here are well known locally and the coffee is praised too. Breakfast items include items such as Green Eggs Sandwiches, Avocado Toast, and Egg And Cheese Omelet.
At lunch, they serve a selection of delicious-sounding sandwiches, wraps, and salads. They also offer vegetarian and gluten-free dishes.
This is one of the best restaurants in Islamorada and you will always leave happy and full.
Bob’s Bunz – Islamorada Restaurant And Bakery
If you are looking for brunch in Islamorada then Bob’s Bunz is a great place to start. This bakery serves diner-style breakfast, brunch, and lunch and has some incredible bakery products.
The menu is extensive and if you have a sweet tooth you are going to love it. The key lime pie, cinnamon rolls, pastries, and cakes are just exquisite.
The Bread Pudding French Toast is a firm favorite here and well worth trying if you visit.
For some of the best dining in Islamorada head to Pierre’s Restaurant. This restaurant is within the Morada Bay hotel and has a stunning location.
This is the perfect restaurant for a special evening with your partner. It’s elegant and decorated in a Colonial style.
The food is a French fusion style with regional influences. Everything about this restaurant is perfect, opulent, and decadent.
The menu includes items such as Charred Sous Vide Spanish Octopus, Thyme Roasted Free Range Chicken, Pan Seared New England Diver Scallops, and Roasted Summer Vegetable Tartlet. It’s elevated food and is so delicious.
This is one of the best restaurants in Islamorada, Florida, and really is a place to be experienced.
Whale Seafood Feast
The Whale Seafood Feast has been part of the local community for over 100 years. The Food Network named it “One of the best seafood restaurants in the country”.
The seafood buffet is huge with over 85 items to choose from. The raw bar offers crab legs, oysters, mussels, and shrimp. There are also meat, poultry, and vegetable dishes available.
Examples of the buffet items are Maryland Blue Crabs, Smoked Fish Dip, Carved Roast Beef, Cedar Plank Salmon, Crab Cakes, Grilled Mahi Mahi, and Ceviche. This is only an example of course but you can see how diverse is it.
If you are looking for a seafood buffet in Islamorada then this is it.
As you can when it comes to restaurants in Islamorada there are so many to choose from. We hope this article helps you decide where to eat in Islamorada.
We have included what we feel are the best restaurants in Islamorada that serve some of the best food in Islamorada. Dining in Islamorada is a real treat with all the great seafood and waterside restaurants.
We hope you have a great trip and please come back and tell us all about it.